Sales call reviews

10 Shocking AI vs Human Sales Analysis Results: Why AI Failed

ai-vs-human-sales-analysis-results
Written by
Published on
Share This

AI vs human sales analysis revealed surprising results. Can AI give you reasonable and interesting thoughts and ideas and advises on how you can make your conversations better? Absolutely. Can you fully rely just on learning from AI? I wouldn’t suggest it.

AI vs human sales analysis comparison shows the biggest problem was that the AI is missing context of where like where are they in the conversation. Today we are finishing reviewing the call analysis that compares AI software with human sales experience.

Who’s better? Somebody that is already having some sort of sales experience, or AI software that can analyze your transcripts?

By the way, for the full context of this article and what we are reviewing here, it might be helpful for you to watch the first part of this call review that I have done, click here https://wehes.com/sales-call-review-27-mistakes/

The Ultimate AI vs Human Sales Analysis Experiment

What are we going to do today? We’re going to take a look at the call analysis. The AI is going to give us the squeezed out version of improvements that should be done with that call.

This AI vs human sales analysis experiment will show you exactly where artificial intelligence falls short in understanding sales conversations.

Probably you’re watching this. If you still haven’t tried doing this, possibly you’re living under the rug. What’s happening with you, brother? It’s 2025.

You can forget about the sales trainers, the people having experiences. Just erase everybody, unfollow everybody. You can pour in all of your transcripts of your calls to the AI software and let them analyze it.

Nobody’s going to know. Nobody’s going to know. Or they will know. They’re already logging everything. But forget about it.

I needed the transcription and the translation for the video purposes. I was like, well, I don’t use the AI to analyze my calls. But I was like, OK, let’s see what does that say?

The idea of comparing my suggestions with the AI suggestions came up to my mind. And this is what happened in this AI vs human sales analysis.

AI vs Human Sales Analysis: Breaking Down Each AI Suggestion

Let’s dive in and let’s take a look. So this is the AI suggestions from our AI vs human sales analysis comparison.

Replace the Product Focus Opening with the Problem Focus

Yeah, so that’s kind of good, but I wouldn’t use like these words, I wouldn’t ask like a biggest challenge. Right. So I already gave a suggestion on this in my AI vs human sales analysis.

I would say like, hey, so we’re here. So you possibly here to look and find the ways and how to attract the better clients on Instagram.

So I would do this instead of like the understand the situation. So it’s like questionable suggestion, I would say.

Stop Pitching Features Early, Build the Pain First

Yep, this is like super like legit advice, right. Building the pain first. And this is what I have allocated as well in this AI vs human sales analysis.

So well, I’m smart as the AI, right.

AI vs Human Sales Analysis: Use the Consequence Questions Instead of Leading Questions

Yeah, legit. Right. So there was a consequence missing. So this is a good one in our AI vs human sales analysis experiment.

Replace Assumptive Closes with the Problem or Question

This is more like a consequence question right here. Yeah. So, well, I would say that at this point, I would say, so where do you want to move forward? Right. I would keep this one during the close.

And this is more like a consequence question. So questionable suggestion in this AI vs human sales analysis.

Handle Money Objections with the Reframes, Not the Pressure

Possibly good one. Right. So instead of Christina most probably knows it, that she should shouldn’t put too much of the pressure on the prospects and asking the questions. So this is OK.

I would say I’m just going to give a green one to this one in our AI vs human sales analysis.

Create the Urgency

Yeah, well, definitely using the words you’ve mentioned. Don’t want to spend the time like reviewing this one.

Use Permission Based Selling Instead of Direct

Well, it’s all so I wouldn’t. And this is an inappropriate suggestion because they already like the deal is already closed. They’re talking about the logistics. Right.

This shows why AI vs human sales analysis reveals context problems.

Replace the Qualification Question with Tonality Based Probing

Yeah, this sounds like a better question, right? Because it gives you more. It looks like it gives you more goals. You should put the price tag on the more goals that you want to acquire to talk about your financial goal.

Right. But it still is just the number. Right.

So I would like I would say the question is good. I’m just going to put it in a yellow. Right.

But me talking about the income that the prospect want to generate, I would focus more on the outcomes that the prospect want to have in their life because of that money that they will have.

And how is that going to make them feel rather than just, well, if you want to drive the Lambo, right, have a have like three Rolexes, how much money you need?

It’s not the owning the Lambo that gives you the feeling, it’s the driving the Lambo and being a man who have the Lambo.

Build the Gap Awareness Before the Solutions

Again, this is not relevant. I mean, it’s already she’s already explaining the deliverables of the program. So clearly, I don’t understand like where we are in the conversation.

This AI vs human sales analysis shows AI missing crucial context clues.

Use Emotional Consequence Questions for Commitment

Possibly this is like a correct. But this one, once again.

So I know why Christina asked this question. Right. I wouldn’t ask no people about the time at all. Right. Because if you build enough urgency, they will find the time to solve it. Right.

So I would just remove it from the script. And well, as a question, this might not wouldn’t be bad dealing your price. It’s more like a consequence question again.

Right. It’s not that you should like change this question with this one.

The Shocking AI vs Human Sales Analysis Results: 7 Failures Out of 10

So what do we see here? Like a couple of like good suggestions here. So less than a half sounds reasonable. Then some questionable and wrong advises.

So what’s the overall conclusion in this AI vs human sales analysis? Right.

Can AI give you reasonable and interesting thoughts and ideas and advises on how you can make your conversations better? Absolutely. Right.

Can you fully rely just on learning from AI? I wouldn’t suggest it. Right.

Because as we already seen in this AI vs human sales analysis, the biggest problem was that the AI is missing context of where like where are they in the conversation? What should happen there? Right. So there’s something there’s a disconnect. Right.

Why AI vs Human Sales Analysis Shows Context Problems

The biggest problem was that the AI is missing context of where like where are they in the conversation? What should happen there? Right. So there’s something there’s a disconnect.

This AI vs human sales analysis experiment proves that artificial intelligence struggles with conversational context. According to sales training experts, understanding conversation flow is crucial for effective sales coaching.

Love me or hate me. You know, throw your comments that maybe my prompt wasn’t as good as they should be. Right. Or maybe there’s a better AI who can actually do it.

But currently you can try and pick a couple of ideas. Right. But it’s going to be hard for you to estimate and evaluate which of these suggestions is actually right or wrong and which ones is in the middle like 50 50.

Research from Harvard Business Review shows that AI tools still require human oversight for complex analysis tasks like sales conversation evaluation.

AI vs Human Sales Analysis: The Final Verdict After 90 Minutes

So that’s up to you whether you’re going to use AI or not.

This is the scores that we got today from our AI vs human sales analysis. And maybe I don’t know, maybe in a quarter in a year, we’re going to do it once again and going to see where is AI at that time.

The question remains: Who’s better? Somebody that is already having some sort of sales experience like this guy over here, or AI software that can analyze your sales calls?

The Truth About AI vs Human Sales Analysis Performance

You can pour in all of your transcripts of your calls to the AI software and let them analyze it. But the biggest problem was that the AI is missing context of where like where are they in the conversation.

If you still haven’t tried it, go play around with it. It’s 2025. But remember – it’s going to be hard for you to estimate and evaluate which of these suggestions is actually right or wrong and which ones is in the middle like 50 50.

This AI vs human sales analysis shows that while technology advances, human expertise remains irreplaceable for nuanced sales situations.

What This AI vs Human Sales Analysis Means for Sales Training

Can AI give you reasonable and interesting thoughts and ideas and advises on how you can make your conversations better? Absolutely.

Can you fully rely just on learning from AI? I wouldn’t suggest it.

You can forget about the sales trainers, the people having experiences. Just erase everybody, unfollow everybody. But the reality is that AI software still has limitations when it comes to understanding sales conversation context.

Our AI vs human sales analysis revealed that artificial intelligence got less than half the suggestions right, proving human experience still trumps automated analysis.

For more insights on effective sales methodology frameworks, consider exploring proven human-led approaches that complement AI tools.

Your Next Steps: Combining AI vs Human Sales Analysis Insights

So what’s the overall conclusion from this AI vs human sales analysis? Right.

Less than a half sounds reasonable. Then some questionable and wrong advises. The AI suggestions included good advice like building the pain first, using consequence questions, and handling money objections with reframes not pressure.

But the AI also gave inappropriate suggestions when it couldn’t understand where they are in the conversation or what should happen there.

The Balanced Approach to AI vs Human Sales Analysis

Maybe in a quarter in a year, we’re going to do it once again and going to see where is AI at that time.

Until then, you can try and pick a couple of ideas from AI analysis. But it’s going to be hard for you to estimate and evaluate which of these suggestions is actually right or wrong without human sales experience to guide you.

The grand finale of this AI vs human sales analysis? AI can provide interesting thoughts and ideas, but somebody that is already having some sort of sales experience will still understand context better than AI software.

Why This AI vs Human Sales Analysis Matters for Your Business

This AI vs human sales analysis experiment demonstrates that while artificial intelligence tools can offer valuable suggestions, they cannot replace the nuanced understanding that comes from real sales experience.

The 90 minutes spent analyzing the call transcript revealed insights that AI missed in its rapid analysis. This AI vs human sales analysis proves that context, timing, and conversational flow require human interpretation.

If you want to improve your sales performance, consider using AI as a supplement to, not a replacement for, experienced sales coaching and training.

So hopefully you enjoyed this AI vs human sales analysis experiment. Share the love, brother or the sister. What would you want to see in the next video?

This comprehensive AI vs human sales analysis shows that the future of sales training lies in combining artificial intelligence insights with human expertise for optimal results.

Before you go... We'd love to help you

15-Minute Callback ☕

Leave your number and we'll call you back in 15 minutes. If we don't, coffee's on us!

Review Your Cart
0
Add Coupon Code
Subtotal